THE STORY
Reported Haunting
The historic Black Horse Inn building has been associated with reports of paranormal activity from employees and patrons. Accounts include unexplained footsteps, unusual noises, and other disturbances believed to be connected to former occupants of the property.
The building dates back to 1773. It was once Black Horse Inn, but is now a restaurant called Stemie’s Place. It’s said that in the old inn days (in 1927, to be exact), a mobster was shot in the hall near the restrooms. After a dramatic fall down the stairs, he hit his head and died at the bottom. His ghost is rumored to haunt the establishment.