THE STORY
Reported Haunting
Casey's Cottage is said to be haunted by the spirit of a former resident who continues to watch over the historic lakeside home. Visitors have reported hearing footsteps, doors moving on their own, and seeing shadow figures inside the cottage. Others describe sudden cold spots and an unexplained feeling of being watched.
Casey’s Cottage was once the 1906 Mexico Point Club House, and was renovated into a medieval manor house by Dr. William C. (Bill) Casey and Severin Bischof. After Dr. Casey passed away in 1978, the cottage was abandoned for years but has since been restored and can be rented for events. Legend has it that a young woman was buried under a tree on the property, and witnesses have seen her apparition and heard her cries for assistance coming from the area of the lake. Also reported here have been fast-moving apparitions, moving furniture, missing objects that turn up in weird places, orbs, cold spots, disembodied voices and more.