THE STORY
Reported Haunting
The 1886 Costello Street Coffee House, once a private home, is purported to house the ghost of former owner James Costello, who passed away there.
The 1886 Costello Street Coffee House, once a private home, is purported to house the ghost of former owner James Costello, who passed away there. Costello’s wife Catherine also died here when her dress caught fire. The restaurant’s ghosts are said to turn lights on, play with animated holiday figures, make footsteps when no one living is around, move or hide various objects, and create cold spots.